Thursday, 3 May 2012


April 28, 2012
Join Russia and USA by Rail Tunnels under the Bering Strait?

By rail, from New York to Moscow, and on to London! Only a 10,000 kilometer gap to fill in this bird's eye view of a trans Bering rail link. Map: Victor Razbegin
Russia’s Urals oil has been over $100 a barrel for a year now.
The country’s budgets are balanced. Debt is low. Savings are piling up. Russians are getting their pre-recession mojo back.
On the consumer end, sales of foreign cars made in Russia jumped 90 percent during the first quarter of 2012 over last year.
In the Kremlin, leaders are thinking big again.
In rapid succession, the government leaked a plan to create a “super agency” to develop the Russian Far East; President-elect Vladimir Putin vowed to spend $17 billion a year for new and improved railroads, and Vladimir Yakunin, president of Russian Railways, promoted a think big plan — a rail and tunnel link connecting Russia and the United States.
“It is not a dream,” Yakunin, a close ally of Mr. Putin, told reporters last week. “I am convinced that Russia needs the development of areas of the Far East, Kamchatka. I think that the decision to build must be made within the next three-five years.”
Next year, Russia’s railroad czar will open one big leg on the trip toward the Bering Strait – an 800 kilometer rail line to Yakutsk, capital of Sakha Republic, a mineral rich area larger than Argentina.
Moscow-born Fyodor Soloview lives in Anchorage, Alaska, where he lobbies for uniting his two homelands, Russia and the United States, with rail tunnels under the Bering Strait. Photo: Soloview
But the 270,000 residents of Yakutsk do not want to live at the dead end of a spur line. They dream of five kilometer long freight trains rolling past their city, carrying Chinese goods to North America, and North American coal and manufactured products to Russia and China.
From their city, 450 kilometers south of the Arctic Circle, passenger tickets could be sold west to London, and east to New York.
With the West’s swelling population of aging affluent retirees, what better gift for Mom and Dad than a one-month train trip, rolling across the International Dateline, traveling by rail three quarters of the way around the world? A TransBering rail voyage would make the TransSiberian and the TransCanada look like short hops.
To push thinking along, Yakutsk hosted a trans Bering rail conference last August. Engineers showed charts indicating that the tunnels under the Bering Strait would be 103 kilometers long, about twice the length of the tunnel under the English Channel. Unlike Europe’s “Chunnel,” there are two islands along the Bering route – geographical factors that would ease construction and allow for ventilation and emergency access.
For now, the only trains in Alaska run from Seward on the coast 760 kilometers into the interior, carrying tourists to Denali National Park and freight to two military bases. Photo: Fyodor Soloview
A trans Bering rail link was first seriously proposed by Czar Nicholas II in 1905. One century later, with the rise of China and the explosion of Asian manufacturing, some Russian economists believe that the day is near when a rail link to North America up would be economically viable.
The current price tag for the missing 10,000 kilometers, tunnel included: $100 billion. Freight fees are estimated at $11 billion a year.
Russian Railways estimates that a Bering Strait tunnel could eventually handle 3 percent of the world’s freight cargo. Yakunin says that China is interested in the project. At a railway meeting in Moscow Thursday, Mr. Putin said that freight traffic on a main Siberian line, the Baikal-Amur Mainline, is expected to nearly triple by 2020.
To critics who worry about harsh winter weather, Russian Railways notes that since 1915, the company has been running passenger and freight trains year round to Murmansk, located 300 miles north of the Arctic Circle. The proposed route for a tunnel under the Bering Strait would pass 50 kilometers south of the Arctic Circle.
Trans Bering rail promoters envisage building feeder lines to connect 'stranded' mineral deposits and to allow shipment of freight between North American and Russia, China, Japan and the Korean peninsula. Map: InterBering
For a tunnel linking two continents, support has to be generated on the North American side. In Alaska, Fyodor Soloview, a native of Moscow, recently formed InterBering, a private group to lobby for rail construction to the Bering Strait.
“We can ship cargo between two the continents by rail,” Soloview said by telephone Thursday from his office in Anchorage. “Once the Bering tunnel is built, it will convert the entire world to different thinking.”
Yakunin estimates that the Russian side of a trans Bering railroad would take 10 to 15 years to build. That could fit into the political calendar of his friend Mr. Putin. On May 7, Mr. Putin will be inaugurated for a new six year term. He has left open the possibility of running in 2018 for another six year term.
So Russian Railways may have the political cover for another 12 years.
The question is whether oil prices will stay high enough to build a tunnel linking America and Asia.
If so, Washington’s diplomatic reset with Moscow could be welded in steel.
To reconnect Asia and North America -- after a 15,000-year separation -- engineers would dig two 103-kilometer long tunnels, each about twice as long as the rail tunnels opened under the English Channel in 1994. Diagrams: Victor Razbegin
On the North American side, almost 5,000 kilometer to track would have to be laid to connect with the existing North American freight network: east from the Bering Strait to Fairbanks, Alaska, and then southeast to Fort Nelson, British Columbia, Canada. Map: InterBering

4 Responses to “Join Russia and USA by Rail Tunnels under the Bering Strait?”

  1. bill says:
    It sounds like a great idea. But has anyone thought about the enviromental impact by trying to develop russias far east. Its the most preserved ecological area on the planet. I hope the greedy politicians in moscow understand that the balance of nature is much more important than lining your pockets with money wich you cant take with you when ya die. Dont forget greed is a deadly sin. Hopefully they can put nature first before there greedy ideology. Maybe the biggest nature reaerve and park in the world. Then the train would be a great idea for tourism rather than depleting the natural resources of russias pristine nature. Having such a park and nature preserve would be the greatest single achievment in the history of mankind. Think about that mr putin.
  2. Shaon Boa says:
    As I understand, the railroad to the eastmost point of Chukotka will be built up in any case and at any price. Though it will take the long time and a deal of money. We just need it to connect the russian regions and to give the cheap goods to our Far East. It is like the Liferoad for Chukotka and Kolyma. Then the living standard in northern-east Russia will go up immediately.
    But the tunnel is an expensive infrastructural object which can be fulfilled only together with the USA and Canada.
    Now it sounds fantastically.
    But when the first train will come to Anadyr` how it is shown on the map, the americans will start to think.
  3. jbrooke says:
    Shaon
    I agree.
    At this point, the US does not seem to be in the mood to undertake big infrastructure projects. in the 2010s, we are not ready to take on a 1960s style Moon Project — however if Russia starts to meet the US halfway, this mood could change.
    Jim
    Moscow
  4. Marco Murr says:
    A Bering Strait rail crossing? Not. It’s a 21st Century challenge for engineers, but in actuality, a plethora of headaches and later, regrets. In the unlikely event the idea were ever approved, the first phase of development would consist of constant arguments in both congresses, and among lobbing firms as to which side of the Straits has the most appropriate engineering ideas. Accusations and criticism from each government and each engineering firm would flow left and right. Of course, the “rich” country (and its citizens) would have to pay for most all of the cost overruns, of which there would be many, accompanied by finger-pointing and accusations between the two sides, as for why. Politicians would have a field day. The two main criminal mafias would get involved in it all. Labor unions would go nuts. Congress would have to hold hearings, and often. The whole thing would eventually become an irresistible target for those who want to terrorize. At some point the United Nations would want to get involved and control some aspect of the project. The main crossing in the Straits would, of course, be shut down for “maintenance” every time there was some grand political disagreement between the two major “partners”. And, given the political history of the two sides, when one side inevitably discovers an embarrassing mechanical problem, it would naturally blame the other side for its cause. Along with the denials, nothing would get repaired on time. Looking at the railroad passenger complement is interesting. All one has to do is examine existing European border problems, and then imagine the possibilities for infiltrating a train on its way across a USA-Russia border. Such a crossing would be a magnet for criminals, spies, terrorists, crazies, illegal immigrants, troublemakers, TV camera crews, Hollywood camera crews, politicians and dumb (mostly American) tourists. And you think we have immigration problems now! There would be a constant whining with accusations each and every time one side refused entry of a citizen from the other side. With the mafia infiltrating the whole scheme, new books would have to be written: “Murder on the Great Bering Express – Part XXII.” In a perfect world it’s a nice idea. In the real world, don’t we already have enough problems between the two most powerful nation states?

No comments:

Post a Comment